Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Irrelevant Questions from the NC Driver's Test

Question 1: How many points do each of the following traffic violations incur: passing a school bus, reckless driving, littering from a motor vehicle?

Answer I Would Have Given If It Were Write-In and Not Multiple Choice:
Who cares? Before doing any of them, am I going to stop and think, "Oh, passing a school bus, that's 5 points, guess I better not," or "Littering, 1 point, no biggie, I'll just toss this soda cup right out my window." Does it matter how many points each incurs? They're all illegal, and if you get caught doing any of them you're going to be in trouble. Period. End of story.

Question 2: For how long is your driver's license suspended if you're caught driving while impaired?

Answer I Would Have Given If It Were Write-In and Not Multiple Choice:
Probably not long enough. And again, does it matter? You shouldn't operate a motor vehicle while impaired by drugs or alcohol, because A) it's just plain stupid, and B) it's also illegal. If you're dumb enough to do it anyway, the length of time your license will be suspended probably doesn't figure into your decision. Can we just make this a true/false question stating that your driver's license will be suspended (Period. End of story.) if you drive while impaired? Thanks.

Question 3: What percentage of traffic fatalities are caused by drunk drivers?

Answer I Would Have Given If It Were Write-In and Not Multiple Choice:
I have no freaking idea, but I do know that even one death is too many. Beyond that, numbers are irrelevant. Period. End of story.

My main objection to all three of these questions is that they have absolutely no bearing on your ability to operate a motor vehicle. Because someone knows that reckless driving is going to result in four points on their license doesn't mean they're not going to do it. And it's not a fear of raising the percentage of deaths caused by drunk drivers that's going to stop someone from getting behind the wheel after drinking. These trivia facts may win me a round at pub quiz one of these days, but they're not going to make anyone a better driver.

Why not ask questions that matter? Such as when do you not have to stop for a stopped school bus? (A: When on a divided highway or a four-lane or bigger road with a middle lane). Or who has the right of way when two cars approach a four-way stop at the same time? (A: The car to the right). Or when is it okay to run over pedestrians? (A: Never.) From my experience driving around here, those are the questions that people really need to know the answers to.

But, I guess I shouldn't expect better. When has anyone ever known the DMV to make sense?

(For the curious, the correct answers are: 5 points for passing a school bus, 4 points for reckless driving, 1 point for littering; 1 year; and 38%. Of course, except for the drunken driving fatality statistic, those are the answers just for here in North Carolina. You could be wrong if you provided these answers on another state's test, which I'm sure has some equally irrelevant questions.)

7 comments:

Cat Scott said...

Amen, sister!! This must be why Los Angelenos don't know how to follow the rules of the road; because they're brains are full of information like how many feet behind a semi a motorcyclist must turn on his blinker!

Rebecca said...

Didn't going to the DMV to take the written test make you feel like you were 16 again?

When I finally switched over to my (ugly) Ohio license, I think I might have been the only one in the written test area without a parent present.

Jessica Flynn said...

did you pass?

Matthew said...

There seems to be a social-class bias to this exam - as with most exams - as those who will do the best will be those with the "down time" to study. Those with power love to test everyone else on "knowledge" as trivial knowledge has nothing to do with actual practice. The final test is based in the activity of driving, but you have to pass the knowledge test to get to the actual driving test. Nothing here is surprising, but the actual questions you had to answer do remind us how stupid such examinations are.

I don't think Caroline had to take any tests to get her KY license. They just gave her a new license.

Theresa said...

We didn't have to take a test in MD. We just showed that we had a valid license from another state, and they converted it into a MD license. Here we had to do the written test, but not the driving test.

I do now have a NC license. Actually I have a piece of paper saying that sometime in the next 20 days I'll have an actual license. "To prevent fraud," they don't give you your license in person but mail it to you. Explain to me how that works?

Jessica Flynn said...

Ugh. Is that what I have to look forward to if/when we move to NC?

Anonymous said...


[url=http://shensacen.eklablog.com/][b]sac longchamp[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyiss.webs.com/][b]sac longchamp[/b][/url]
[url=http://shensacen.publr.com/][b]sac longchamp[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyii.angelfire.com/][b]sac longchamp[/b][/url]
[url=http://www.squidoo.com/shensacens][b]sac longchamp[/b][/url]